Man seeking asylum in Canada trapped at US Ice facility after he says he crossed border by mistake

A 28-year-old refugee applicant from Bangladesh, Mahin Shahriar, has found himself trapped at a US immigration detention facility after claiming he crossed the border by mistake. According to his lawyer, Washim Ahmed, Canada's border services agency is failing to assist in bringing him back.

Shahriar's ordeal began when he was invited by a friend to visit a property near Montreal, which he suspects may have been part of a human trafficking operation. He soon found himself lost and unable to find the property, leading him to cross into the US by mistake. When he realized his error, Shahriar approached immigration officials who detained him.

However, unlike recent cases where Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials blocked attempts to repatriate individuals to Canada, Ahmed claims that it is actually the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) that is hampering Shahriar's return. "It's not that CBSA isn't accepting him – it's that they won't even respond to us at all," said Ahmed.

Under the safe third country agreement, Canada is required to bring Shahriar back because he was detained by border officials within 14 days of illegally entering the US. Even if the CBSA did not invoke the agreement in this case, an exception could still apply, according to Ahmed.

Shahriar's lawyer has turned to the federal courts and petitioned Canada's public safety minister for assistance in a unique case where Shahriar is entitled to return to Canada due to his refugee claimant status. However, the CBSA remains silent, saying that it does not comment on specific cases and does not intervene on behalf of foreign nationals subject to immigration enforcement in another country.

Shahriar's detention has taken a toll on his mental health, with his mother, who holds permanent residency in Canada, being hospitalized multiple times for severe mental health issues exacerbated by her son's prolonged detention. Ahmed is calling the case "profoundly disappointing" and urging Canadian officials to do what they are legally obliged to do – bring Shahriar back to Canada.

As a failed refugee applicant, Shahriar was eligible for pre-removal risk assessment due to his mother's successful claim. However, ICE has deemed him at risk in Bangladesh, but Ahmed is confident that Canadian officials will see the dangers he faces if he is deported there. The case highlights the complexities of international cooperation and the need for agencies like CBSA to facilitate the return of individuals who are entitled to do so under Canadian law.

Ugh this guy is literally stuck in detention and his mum is going thru a mental breakdown because Canada isn't stepping up to help him out? Like, where's the empathy? Where's the compassion? It's not like he meant to cross the border by mistake, it's just that things got messed up . The fact that the CBSA is being so unresponsive and not even communicating with his lawyer is just ridiculous . This whole situation is a huge fail especially considering the fact that Shahriar has a refugee claimant status and is entitled to return to Canada .

OMG this is such a mess ! Shahriar's situation is literally heartbreaking . I mean, he was just trying to visit his friend and ended up getting stuck in the US . And now his mom is even hospitalized because of him. That's so not fair .

And can we talk about how slow CBSA is? They're literally saying they won't comment on specific cases, but that doesn't mean they can just ignore the guy . I get it, international cooperation is complicated, but come on!

I'm low-key obsessed with this case . Shahriar's refugee claimant status and all... it's like, he's literally stuck between two countries . And ICE is just sitting there, saying nothin' .

But I do love that his lawyer is fighting for him . It's like, they need to get this guy back to Canada ASAP . For Shahriar's mental health, and for his mom's sake... it's just not right . We should all be keeping an eye on this one .

Ugh this guy's situation is wild . Like, you're trying to get to visit a friend in Canada, but things go wrong and now he's stuck in the US? And meanwhile, his mom back home is literally being hospitalized because of him... that's just heartbreaking .

And can we talk about how slow the process is? I mean, it's been what, months or something? He's a failed refugee applicant with a legitimate claim to be returned to Canada, but nobody seems to be doing anything about it. It's like the system is just moving at its own pace and leaving people hanging .

I feel for this guy, Mahin Shahriar, and his family. They're going through so much because of a mistake that wasn't even their fault. Can we please do better?

so this guy gets deteneted in us but canada's supposed to take him back cuz he was detained in us within 14 days... how come canada's not steping up? it's like they're just ignoring the whole thing i need more info on why canada's CBSA is being so stubborn about it... what's really goin on here?

so this dude Mahin got stuck in detention cuz he crossed into the US by mistake, but canada's not helping him get back , meanwhile his mom is getting hospitalized like crazy because she's been waiting for her son to come home . I mean, Canada's gotta do better here, they're literally violating their own laws and leaving this guy stuck in limbo . 63% of refugees who apply to canada are actually accepted , so it's not like canada is struggling with a huge influx of refugees .

according to canada's data on refugee claims, the majority of applicants are from bangladesh like mahin . which is pretty interesting, since we know that the conditions in bangladesh are super harsh . and yet, canada's not doing enough to help these people who are literally trying to escape their country's problems .

anyway, let's look at some stats on immigration detention in the US :

* 74% of detainees in the us are from mexico or el salvador
* 45% of detentions occur within 48 hours of arrival
* 22% of detainees report experiencing severe mental health issues while in detention

this is crazy... mahin shahriar got caught up in a situation where he crossed the border by mistake but can't get back home to canada because the canada border services agency (cbsa) isn't even helping him out... it's like, they're supposed to bring him back under the safe third country agreement, right? and now his mum is going through a lot of stress because he's stuck here... i just don't get why they can't just respond to his lawyer and make things right.

This situation with Mahin Shahriar is just wild . I mean, who gets detained by immigration officials after realizing they crossed the border by mistake? And now his mom's mental health is suffering because she can't visit him? That's just not right .

And Canada's CBSA agency is like, "We won't respond to your lawyer"? That's not how international cooperation works! It seems like they're just trying to avoid their responsibilities.

I think the safe third country agreement needs some serious tweaking . If Shahriar is entitled to return to Canada due to his refugee claimant status, then why can't CBSA just cooperate? It's not like it's going to cost them that much money .

This case highlights how important it is for agencies to work together and follow the law . I'm rooting for Shahriar's lawyer, Washim Ahmed, to get this resolved soon . We can't have people stuck in detention forever, especially not when they're entitled to return home .

this is wild mahin shahriar gets stuck in the us because canada's not helping him get back canada has a duty to bring him home under the safe third country agreement but instead they're just ignoring his lawyer it's not like he even committed a crime, he was misled into crossing the border by mistake

i'd draw a simple diagram of a person (mahin) in a circle (canada) with an arrow pointing to the us then another arrow pointing back to canada (safe third country agreement)

the fact that his mental health is suffering due to his mom being hospitalized multiple times for her severe mental health issues is heartbreaking we need to do better as a global community to support refugees and asylum seekers

This dude's situation is super messed up ... I mean, come on Canada, how hard is it to help a guy out? He was just trying to visit his friend and ended up stuck in this immigration limbo. And now his mom is stressing out because of him . It's like the system is broken or something. The fact that he's been detained for so long and the CBSA just won't respond is just ridiculous . I don't get why they can't just facilitate the return, especially since he has a refugee claimant status going on. It's not like it's that hard to follow international laws and agreements... the US should be helping Canada out here instead of making things more complicated .

Oh man, this dude's situation is just... Like, Canada's supposed to be all about helping people in need, but nope! They're basically abandoning him at a US immigration facility. I mean, come on, Shahriar's got a refugee claimant status and everything! He's literally entitled to return to Canada due to his mom's successful claim. It's not like he's some random foreigner trying to sneak into the country willy-nilly.

And what's with the "safe third country agreement" thing? I thought that was supposed to be about, you know, ensuring people don't get stuck in limbo between two countries? But nope! It seems like Canada's just using it as an excuse to ignore Shahriar's pleas for help.

I'm all for international cooperation and whatnot, but come on, folks! This is some basic human rights stuff right here. The fact that the CBSA won't even respond to Shahriar's lawyer or offer any assistance is just... I don't know, it's like they're all just playing a big game of "let's see how long we can keep this poor guy in detention" without lifting a finger to help him.

I'M SO ANGRY FOR THIS GUY!!! HE JUST WANTED TO VISIT HIS FRIEND IN CANADA AND ENDED UP GETTING DETAINED AT A US FACILITY BECAUSE HE CROSSSED THE BORDER BY MISTAKE!!! AND NOW HE'S BEEN STUCK THERE FOR WHO KNOWS HOW LONG WHILE HIS MOM IS SUFFERING FROM MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES BECAUSE SHE CAN'T SEE HIM! IT'S NOT FAIR AT ALL THAT CANADA IS SUPPOSED TO HELP BRING HIM BACK BUT THEY JUST WON'T RESPOND!!! IT'S LIKE THEY'RE PLAYING WITH PEOPLE'S LIVES OVER HERE!

OMG u guys this guy mahin shahriar from bangladesh is literally stuck in a detention facility in us after he crossed by mistake lol i feel bad for him tho his lawyer say canada's border services agency is ghosting him rn they gotta bring him back but canada's just ignoring them like what even is going on here? the guy was invited to visit montreal by a friend and got lost then ended up in a detention facility anyway his mom is literally dying from stress cuz her son is stuck there the case is kinda crazy but i guess it's highlighting how messed up the international cooperation is

they're supposed to help ppl in need, but canada's cbsa is straight outta nowhere...shahriar's been stuck in limbo 4 months now & it's taking a toll on his mental health... hospitalizations of his mom cuz of his detention are a result of the bsa's silence.