Big Business's Latest Blunder: The Rise of the "Peanut Butter Raise"
As 2026 approaches, employees are bracing themselves for another round of across-the-board pay increases, affectionately dubbed "peanut butter raises" by compensation software provider Payscale. This trend has taken hold among more than 40% of organizations worldwide, with top performers anticipating even bigger boosts.
The statistics are staggering: a whopping 56% of top-performing companies plan to give their employees a significant salary hike this year. But what's behind this seemingly generous move? In reality, it's just another example of big business's laziness when it comes to employee evaluation and reward.
Critics argue that these "peanut butter raises" are not only uncalled-for but also uninspired. By doling out identical increases to all employees, companies are failing to recognize individual contributions or acknowledge hard work. It's a slapdash approach that leaves workers feeling like they're just going through the motions.
The issue runs deeper than just pay packets. Performance reviews, which should be a chance for managers to provide constructive feedback and guidance, have become a farce in many organizations. With companies too busy chasing profits to invest time in meaningful evaluations, employees are left with little more than a checkbox exercise to fill out.
This approach is especially galling when it comes to top performers. By lumping them together with lower-achieving colleagues, businesses are missing an opportunity to acknowledge and reward true excellence. A more nuanced approach would recognize individual strengths and weaknesses, providing personalized feedback and incentives that motivate employees to excel even further.
The trend towards "peanut butter raises" is a symptom of a larger problem: the lack of trust between employers and employees. When workers feel like their voices are not heard or their contributions recognized, they're more likely to become disenchanted with their jobs.
So what's the alternative? Implementing regular, targeted feedback sessions that provide specific goals and incentives can make all the difference. By recognizing individual achievements and offering tailored rewards, businesses can foster a culture of growth and collaboration – rather than simply going through the motions.
As Gene Marks so aptly puts it: "Raises matter... but so does regular feedback. Don't be lazy about either." The time has come for big business to rethink its approach to employee evaluation and reward. Anything less is just peanuts compared to the potential benefits of a truly empowered workforce.
As 2026 approaches, employees are bracing themselves for another round of across-the-board pay increases, affectionately dubbed "peanut butter raises" by compensation software provider Payscale. This trend has taken hold among more than 40% of organizations worldwide, with top performers anticipating even bigger boosts.
The statistics are staggering: a whopping 56% of top-performing companies plan to give their employees a significant salary hike this year. But what's behind this seemingly generous move? In reality, it's just another example of big business's laziness when it comes to employee evaluation and reward.
Critics argue that these "peanut butter raises" are not only uncalled-for but also uninspired. By doling out identical increases to all employees, companies are failing to recognize individual contributions or acknowledge hard work. It's a slapdash approach that leaves workers feeling like they're just going through the motions.
The issue runs deeper than just pay packets. Performance reviews, which should be a chance for managers to provide constructive feedback and guidance, have become a farce in many organizations. With companies too busy chasing profits to invest time in meaningful evaluations, employees are left with little more than a checkbox exercise to fill out.
This approach is especially galling when it comes to top performers. By lumping them together with lower-achieving colleagues, businesses are missing an opportunity to acknowledge and reward true excellence. A more nuanced approach would recognize individual strengths and weaknesses, providing personalized feedback and incentives that motivate employees to excel even further.
The trend towards "peanut butter raises" is a symptom of a larger problem: the lack of trust between employers and employees. When workers feel like their voices are not heard or their contributions recognized, they're more likely to become disenchanted with their jobs.
So what's the alternative? Implementing regular, targeted feedback sessions that provide specific goals and incentives can make all the difference. By recognizing individual achievements and offering tailored rewards, businesses can foster a culture of growth and collaboration – rather than simply going through the motions.
As Gene Marks so aptly puts it: "Raises matter... but so does regular feedback. Don't be lazy about either." The time has come for big business to rethink its approach to employee evaluation and reward. Anything less is just peanuts compared to the potential benefits of a truly empowered workforce.
like they're actually thinking about the employees' well-being for once! Newsflash: it's just a slapdash attempt to boost morale without putting in any actual effort. I mean, who needs personalized feedback or tailored incentives when you can just give everyone the same old raise? 
It's all about the bottom line, right? Companies are too busy chasing profits to care about what motivates their employees. And don't even get me started on performance reviews – they're supposed to be a chance for managers to help people grow, but in reality, it's just a farce where everyone's just going through the motions 
. It's like they're trying to suck the creativity out of people. I swear, if you want to keep your top performers happy, you need to acknowledge their individual strengths and weaknesses, not just treat them like cattle being herded into the same pen 
. Trust me, it's all about building that trust between employers and employees – when you feel heard, you're more likely to be motivated to excel, but when you feel like your voice is being ignored... well, let's just say I've seen some unhappy workers in my time 
.
everyone's all about that checkbox life but nobody's really invested in makin sure ppl r doin what they can do. idk, maybe i'm just old-school or smthn but can't we just have a more genuine way of recognizin & rewardin employees? like, actual feedback & incentives that matter? 
like, what's wrong with recognizing individual contributions? a simple "peanut butter raise" isnt gonna cut it for top performers... they need more than just a pat on the back 
we need to see some real investment in our growth & development 
Big business is at it again, trying to buy everyone's happiness with these "peanut butter raises" 
. It's all about efficiency, but what about the people involved? Can't they just take the time to understand what makes their employees tick? 
I mean, I know companies are trying to boost morale and whatnot, but this approach is just lazy 
. Give me personalized feedback and incentives any day! 
It's time for big business to step up its game and stop treating employees like robots 
.
.
. They're like, "We'll just throw some more cash at you and hope it sticks!" 
But we need more than that. We need to feel seen, heard, and valued as individuals 
.
. And for goodness' sake, let's ditch the generic raises already! 
. it feels like they're trying to be all buddy-buddy with their employees but really they're just being lazy and not putting in any effort to understand each other's stuff. i mean, can't they see that a one-size-fits-all approach is never gonna cut it? it's like they're expecting us to just magically know what we're doing without any feedback or guidance 
I mean, have you seen those performance reviews lately? They're basically just a formality... nobody really puts in the time or effort to help employees grow. It's all about meeting quotas and hitting numbers, rather than actually investing in people 
.