HSBC's top executives faced intense scrutiny from shareholders in Hong Kong on Monday, with many calling for the bank to break up its Asian business as a way to boost profitability and value.
The lender's chairman, Mark Tucker, and CEO, Noel Quinn, defended the bank's strategy at an informal shareholder meeting, saying that splitting the bank would not be in the best interest of shareholders. However, some shareholders remained skeptical, citing concerns about the bank's underperformance in other regions and the need for a more streamlined business.
One shareholder, Christine Fong, who represents around 500 small investors affected by HSBC's scrapping of its dividend in 2020, argued that the bank's Asian operations are dragging down the rest of the business. She said that if HSBC were to spin off or reorganize its Asian business, it would no longer have to expose Hong Kong shareholders to requests from other jurisdictions.
Despite facing pressure from some shareholders, Ping An Insurance Group, China's largest insurer and HSBC's biggest shareholder, has expressed support for a breakup of the bank. The insurance giant's chairman of asset management arm, Huang Yong, stated in November that he would back any initiatives, including a spinoff of HSBC's Asian business, that could boost its value.
HSBC's acquisition of Silicon Valley Bank's UK arm has also come under scrutiny, with some critics questioning whether the bank carried out adequate due diligence on the customers. However, the bank's executives defended the deal, saying it was a good business opportunity that allowed them to gain hundreds of innovative startups as customers.
The meeting comes at a time of turmoil in the banking sector, with recent collapses and takeovers raising concerns about systemic risk. HSBC's CEO, Noel Quinn, said he did not expect an immediate impact on the bank but acknowledged that there would be a period of uncertainty before nerves settle.
The lender's chairman, Mark Tucker, and CEO, Noel Quinn, defended the bank's strategy at an informal shareholder meeting, saying that splitting the bank would not be in the best interest of shareholders. However, some shareholders remained skeptical, citing concerns about the bank's underperformance in other regions and the need for a more streamlined business.
One shareholder, Christine Fong, who represents around 500 small investors affected by HSBC's scrapping of its dividend in 2020, argued that the bank's Asian operations are dragging down the rest of the business. She said that if HSBC were to spin off or reorganize its Asian business, it would no longer have to expose Hong Kong shareholders to requests from other jurisdictions.
Despite facing pressure from some shareholders, Ping An Insurance Group, China's largest insurer and HSBC's biggest shareholder, has expressed support for a breakup of the bank. The insurance giant's chairman of asset management arm, Huang Yong, stated in November that he would back any initiatives, including a spinoff of HSBC's Asian business, that could boost its value.
HSBC's acquisition of Silicon Valley Bank's UK arm has also come under scrutiny, with some critics questioning whether the bank carried out adequate due diligence on the customers. However, the bank's executives defended the deal, saying it was a good business opportunity that allowed them to gain hundreds of innovative startups as customers.
The meeting comes at a time of turmoil in the banking sector, with recent collapses and takeovers raising concerns about systemic risk. HSBC's CEO, Noel Quinn, said he did not expect an immediate impact on the bank but acknowledged that there would be a period of uncertainty before nerves settle.
. I mean who wants to lose money just because they have a big presence in asia? 
Some people need to focus on the bigger picture here. Its not all about profit, but also about stability and making smart decisions 
. Ping An Insurance Group seems like the only one that understands this. Their chairman is literally saying "we'll back anything that boosts our value" 
- that's a pretty clear message. As for the Silicon Valley Bank acquisition, I don't think HSCB did its due diligence properly either 
. But hey, at least they're trying to make it work. The meeting could be a turning point for the bank and its shareholders. Fingers crossed for a positive outcome 
Like, what happens to all those employees? Who gets left holding the bag? 
And then there's Ping An Insurance Group's support for a breakup... that raises even more questions about the motivations behind it. 
The fact that HSBC's executives are downplaying any potential risks just seems to add to my concerns. 
I guess only time will tell if this breakup idea is the right move for HSBC... but for now, I'm keeping a close eye on it. 
. The banking sector is already unstable, and now we're talking about breaking up a major bank? That just invites more chaos...
? I mean, I get it, the banking sector is a mess right now, but does breaking up HSBC really solve anything? Isn’t that just gonna create more problems down the line? 
. But as someone who doesn’t have a stake in the bank or any of its operations, it just seems like they're playing with fire 
.
.
.
! I mean, can you blame them tho? Asian business is literally sucking up all the profits 
. It's time for HSBC to break up its Asian ops and focus on other regions that are actually doing well 
. Ping An Insurance Group is like, "Yaaas, let's boost our value!" 
This meeting is giving me life, but also anxiety