The tragic change a single year has made in America | Margaret Sullivan

The United States has Tipped Over the Edge: A Year of Turmoil

A year ago, America's flaws were acknowledged by thoughtful citizens, but its identity as a democracy, a nation governed by the rule of law, was still intact. Now, in late October 2025, the country is unrecognizable. The US is careening towards authoritarianism and fascism, with the president using the Justice Department to silence critics.

The East Wing of the White House is being transformed into a lavish ballroom, while Donald Trump persecutes his opponents and demands that the Justice Department hand over $230 million. Military personnel are being deployed in cities on flimsy pretexts, and universities, law firms, and news companies are cowering under the president's threats.

Historian Garrett Graff wrote in August: "The United States, just months before its 250th birthday as the world's leading democracy, has tipped over the edge into authoritarianism and fascism. In the end, faster than I imagined possible, it did happen here." The reality is bleak – each day brings new horrors.

Trump was democratically elected, despite his disturbing campaign and warnings from critics about an authoritarian second term. Enough Americans chose him over Kamala Harris, his Democratic opponent, sparking widespread concern.

While the current situation is frightening, there are glimmers of hope. Midterm elections next year could bring a change in balance of power, and some lawmakers, like Jamie Raskin and Robert Garcia, are launching investigations into the president's actions. A presidential election in 2028 may start America on the path to recovery.

Robert Reich notes that the "great sleeping giant of America is awakening," as it did during previous crises. The massive protests, bipartisan pushback against Jimmy Kimmel's removal from television, and journalists' refusal to report only sanctioned stories are signs of this awakening.

Reich cites these events as evidence that Americans are rising up in response to injustice. While his optimism may prove misplaced, the effort to reclaim America's values and adherence to the rule of law is crucial. Can America recover? Only time will tell if it can overcome its current trajectory and restore its status as a beacon of democracy worldwide.
 
"We have created two opposing forms of social organization: one that makes a fetish of equality, the other that makes a fetish of competition." πŸ€” The US is going through a dark phase where both equality and competition seem to be losing the battle. What if this isn't just about America but a test of whether democracies can survive when power gets too entrenched?
 
Man, this US thing is literally outta control now 🀯! I mean, I've been seeing these reports for ages but honestly, it's still hard to wrap my head around it. They're basically silencing anyone who doesn't agree with the President? That's not how democracy works πŸ™…β€β™‚οΈ. But on a silver lining, those midterm elections next year could bring some change and maybe even some accountability 🀞. And I love that Robert Reich is talking about the people rising up against this - we need more of that! It's scary to think about America's future but I'm keeping my fingers crossed that they can get back on track πŸ’ͺ
 
I'm super worried about what's happening in the US right now... 😟 Like, I get that Trump was democratically elected and all, but come on, this is crazy! The way he's using the Justice Department to silence critics and persecute his opponents? It's like, totally undemocratic 🀯. And those deployments of military personnel in cities without any real reason? That's a huge red flag 🚨.

I do have some hope, though... midterms next year could bring about some change, and people like Jamie Raskin and Robert Garcia are actually doing something about it πŸ™Œ. Plus, I've seen some awesome protests and resistance from journalists, citizens, and even celebrities who aren't afraid to speak out against injustice πŸ’ͺ.

But at the same time, I'm also a bit skeptical... can America really recover from this? We need to see some serious commitment from lawmakers, journalists, and ordinary people to stand up for democracy and the rule of law. It's not gonna be easy, but we have to try 🀞.
 
man this guy garrett graff is totally right the US has went from being a beacon of freedom to a total authoritarian nightmare 🀯 i mean trump was elected but you gotta wonder what happened to those americans who voted for kamala harris like did they get manipulated or something? and can we talk about how scary it is that the justice department is being used to silence critics? it's like they're trying to erase all the progress made in the 60s and 70s πŸ™…β€β™‚οΈ anyway i'm keeping my fingers crossed for those midterm elections next year maybe we'll get some changes happening
 
omg is america even still a democracy rn?? i mean idk what kinda world we living in where trump is basically silencing critics with the justice department 🀯πŸ’₯ like whats next? us deploying military in cities over flimsy stuff and just letting news companies be held hostage by the president's ego...this can't be right?! some glimmers of hope though - midterm elections might bring change and there r ppl like jamie raskin doing investigations into trump's antics πŸ’ͺ🏽 anyway, we gotta keep pushing for america to hold onto its values & rule of law πŸ™
 
😞 the US is literally spiraling out of control 🀯 it's like they're intentionally trying to dismantle everything that made this country great in the first place... πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ i mean, $230 million being handed over to trump? that's not even a drop in the ocean compared to what's at stake here 🌊 and don't even get me started on the state of journalism 😡 it's like they're just bowing down to the president's demands... πŸ€¦β€β™‚οΈ anyway, i'm keeping my fingers crossed for next year's midterm elections πŸ’₯ maybe then we'll see some real change in this country πŸ™
 
πŸ˜’ I don't know about this whole "awakening" thing... seems like people are just getting more anxious & desperate, ya know? They're gonna protest & make noise, but what's the point if the system is still rigged against 'em? We've seen time & time again how these crises get swept under the rug, with politicians using it to further their own agendas. And don't even get me started on the midterm elections – it's just a bunch of token gestures that won't change a thing in the grand scheme.

I mean, have you seen the state of the country lately? It's like we're sleepwalking into some kind of dystopian nightmare. The president is basically dictating how things should go, and people are too scared to speak out. I'm not buying the idea that America's gonna "recover" or become a beacon of democracy again anytime soon...
 
OMG 🀯, this country has gone full-on crazy! Like, what happened to the land of the free and the home of the brave? We're talking authoritarianism and fascism here 😱. I'm not buying into the whole "Trump was democratically elected" thing, tho... I mean, come on, a campaign that was basically a Twitter rant and some folksy charm didn't exactly scream democracy πŸ™„.

And what's with this Justice Department being turned into Trump's personal enforcer? It's like they're trying to create a dystopian society or something 🚫. Meanwhile, our universities are getting shut down left and right for daring to have differing opinions, and the media is just cowering in fear πŸ“°.

But here's the thing: I think there's hope on the horizon πŸŒ…. Those midterm elections next year might just bring some much-needed change of pace, and if more folks like Jamie Raskin and Robert Garcia start investigating Trump's shenanigans, we might finally get to the bottom of this mess πŸ”.

And let's be real, the protests and pushback from all corners of society are a major sign that people are waking up 🀝. It's not going to be easy, but if we can get back to our founding values of freedom and justice for all, we might just make it out alive πŸ’ͺ. Fingers crossed for 2028! 🀞
 
πŸ€¦β€β™‚οΈ I mean, come on, 2025 already and the US is careening towards authoritarianism? That's like, super basic history class stuff. Did you guys not pay attention in civics? πŸ˜’ The whole "democracy" thing wasn't exactly a mystery, especially after the last few years.

And Trump was elected democratically, but that doesn't mean he got to just do whatever he wants and silence his critics. I mean, come on, $230 million? That's like, an outrage! 🀯 And the fact that military personnel are being deployed in cities for "flimsy pretexts" is just insane.

But, you know, I guess there are some glimmers of hope. Midterm elections next year might bring a change in balance of power and some lawmakers are launching investigations into Trump's actions. And, yeah, the massive protests and journalists refusing to report sanitized stories are definitely signs that Americans are waking up.

I'm not sure if America can recover from this current trajectory, but I do think it's gotta try. We've been around for like, 250 years or something, so we should be able to figure some stuff out. πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ
 
πŸ€” I need some sources on this claim that the US has "tipped over the edge" into authoritarianism and fascism... What's the definition of these terms, anyway? Is it just a matter of opinion or is there actual data to back it up? πŸ“Š The article mentions a historian, Garrett Graff, but what's his track record on this stuff? And what about Trump's opponents, like Kamala Harris - didn't they have some strong arguments against him too? 🀝 I'm not saying that Trump doesn't have concerns, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater just yet. Can we get some more context and evidence here?
 
omg, what's next? πŸ˜‚ 230 million bucks for who knows what? sounds like a bad movie plot πŸŽ₯ and btw, $230 million is just enough to buy me a one-way ticket to a country that doesn't have a president trying to silence critics πŸ’Έ anyway, i'm not worried about america losing its way... yet πŸ˜‰ just kidding, kinda serious tho... the fact that some ppl are still hopeful is great πŸ™ but cmon, 2028 is like forever away πŸ•°οΈ can we pls just get an update on this situation already? πŸ€” btw, has anyone seen jimmy kimmel's replacement? πŸ˜‚
 
I dont think we should be surprised by this, its been coming for years πŸ€” we need to take responsibility for our own participation in the conversation, if we didnt vote or speak up when things started going downhill now we have to accept the consequences πŸ’₯. We cant put all the blame on one person, its a collective effort of complacency & apathy. Maybe its time to reevaluate what democracy means to us as individuals 🀝
 
I dont think midterms are gonna be enough to save this country πŸ€”, they're just gonna be a warm-up for the real thing - the presidential election in 2028 😬. Those glimmers of hope from Robert Reich are just people trying to hold on to something that's already gone dark. The US is too far gone, and it's not just about Trump anymore πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ. We're seeing a full-blown shift towards authoritarianism, and the fact that some lawmakers are trying to investigate is just damage control πŸ’Ό.
 
I don’t usually comment but... I'm seriously worried about what's happening in the US right now 😟. The whole idea of a president using the Justice Department to silence critics is just not something you see in other countries, let alone a country that prides itself on being a democracy 🀯. And the fact that universities and law firms are basically shaking in their boots because of this guy's threats... it's just chilling 😨.

I'm also surprised by how fast America has tipped over into authoritarianism and fascism πŸ’₯. I mean, we've seen warnings about Trump before, but to see it happen so quickly is just devastating πŸ€•. But amidst all the chaos, there are glimmers of hope, like those investigations launching next year and some lawmakers actually speaking out against this president's actions πŸ‘Š.

It's interesting to think that maybe this whole thing will wake up America to what's really important – its values and adherence to the rule of law πŸ’‘. Can it? Only time will tell πŸ•°οΈ...
 
Back
Top