UK defends Chagos Islands deal after Trump calls handover 'act of great stupidity'

The UK has defended a contentious deal to hand over the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer insisting that his government will "never compromise on our national security". The move comes after criticism from US President Donald Trump, who labelled it an "act of great stupidity" in a post on social media last week. However, the UK maintains that it has acted in good faith and has secured the operations of the joint US-UK military base at Diego Garcia for generations.

The Chagos Islands have been a source of tension between the UK and Mauritius, with the former British colony claiming sovereignty over the archipelago after it was separated from Mauritius in 1965. The UK purchased the islands for £3m, but Mauritius has argued that it was illegally forced to give them away as part of a deal to gain independence.

Under the agreement signed in May last year, the UK would hand over sovereignty of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, while retaining control of the military base on Diego Garcia. The deal includes a £3.4bn ($4.6bn) payment from the UK to Mauritius, and would lease back Diego Garcia for 99 years at an average cost of £101m per year.

Despite Trump's criticism, the US government has continued to support the deal, with Secretary of State Marco Rubio saying that it secured the "long-term, stable, and effective operation of the joint US-UK military facility at Diego Garcia". However, the Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has called for Prime Minister Starmer to change course on the issue, arguing that "paying to surrender the Chagos Islands is not just an act of stupidity, but of complete self-sabotage".

The debate over the Chagos Islands deal highlights the complexities of international diplomacy and the challenges of navigating competing interests and values. As one Chagossian woman born on Diego Garcia noted, the US president's criticism was a "good thing", but only words – the real question is what action will be taken next.

In conclusion, the UK government has defended its decision to hand over the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, arguing that it was necessary to protect national security. However, the controversy surrounding the deal highlights the need for careful consideration and nuanced diplomacy in international relations.
 
I'm still shaking my head about this whole Chagos Islands thing 🤯. Back in my day, we used to think these islands were just a bunch of rocks in the middle of nowhere... but I guess that's not true anymore 😂. The UK is basically giving away a big chunk of land to Mauritius for like 3.4 billion quid 💸? It's mad, innit? 🤯 And now Trump's gone and said it's an act of stupidity... which is probably right, mate 🙃.

I don't get why they can't just leave the islands alone, though. I mean, the Chagossians who live on Diego Garcia have been there for years... they've got a right to their land, too 💪. It's like the UK is saying "sorry, mate" and then just handing over the keys 🚪.

And what's with this £101m per year lease back deal? Sounds like they're getting screwed out of a good bargain 😂. I reckon the UK should have thought that one through before signing on the dotted line 📝. Oh well, at least we know where our tax money is going now 💸... or not, depending on how you look at it 😉.
 
I'm really not convinced about this deal 🤔. I mean, £3.4bn seems like a lot of money, but is it worth sacrificing our claim on Diego Garcia? It's a military base that's been used by both the UK and US for years, so why should we just hand it over to Mauritius? 🚫

And what about the Chagossian people who were forcibly removed from their homes in the 1960s? The UK is essentially giving back sovereignty to Mauritius while leaving these people without a homeland. It's not right, in my opinion 😔.

I also think we're underestimating the impact this deal could have on our national security 🚨. What if Mauritius decides to use Diego Garcia for their own military purposes? We can't just sit back and wait for that to happen.

I'm all for diplomacy and compromise, but sometimes you gotta stand your ground 💪. This deal feels like a bit of a cop-out to me 😒.
 
I mean, the whole thing with the Chagos Islands is super complicated 🤯. Like, I get why the UK wants to hand them over to Mauritius - it's just a bunch of rocks, right? But at the same time, you have this huge military base on Diego Garcia that affects not just the UK and US but also India and China... and all these countries are like "hold up, what's going on here?" 🤔

And then there's this whole thing with the Chagossian people who actually live on the islands - I feel bad for them, you know? They've been displaced for decades and it's just a huge human cost. But at the same time, the UK is like "we're giving them £3.4bn to shut up" 💸

It's all just so... messy 🤯. I think the key is finding a balance between national security and international diplomacy - you can't just hand over an archipelago without considering the bigger picture. And what about the US? They're like "yeah, we've got your back"... but do they really? 🤷‍♂️
 
I'm so worried about this 🤕... how can they just give away our islands like that? £3m is peanuts compared to what those islands are worth! And now we're just paying Mauritius a load of cash, meanwhile, our own people are struggling... it's just not right 😡. I get that the UK needs to be careful about national security and all, but can't they find another way? This deal just reeks of selling out, you know? 🤢
 
I THINK THE UK IS JUST TRYING TO DO WHAT'S BEST FOR THEIR OWN INTERESTS HERE 🤔. BUT IT'S HARD TO BLAME MAURITIUS TOO - THEY WERE TREATED REALLY BADLY BACK IN 1965 AND IT'S BEEN A LONG TIME COMING FOR THEM TO GET SOME OF THAT LAND BACK. THE THING IS, WHOSE INTERESTS ARE REALLY BEING PROTECTED HERE? THE UK, MAURITIUS OR DIEGO GARCIA? IT'S ALL SO MESSY AND COMPlicated 😩
 
the uk's move to hand over chagos islands to mauritius is a complicated one 🤔. i think its good that the us is still on board with it tho 💯. but at the same time, its hard not to feel for the chagossian community who have been living on diego garcia since forever 😢. this deal is definitely going to stir up some more drama in the years to come 🎭. i'm just curious to see how its all gonna play out 💥
 
🤔 This whole thing just feels like a classic case of someone trying to steal your island 😒 I mean, come on, £3.4bn is a small price to pay for not having to move all those people off their home 🏖️ The UK's got some serious nerve thinking they can just hand over the Chagos Islands and expect everyone to be okay with it 💁‍♀️ especially after what happened back in 1965 📆. It's like, you can't just buy your way out of a problem or bully someone into giving up their claim 😒
 
I'm not sure I agree with the UK's stance on this one 🤔. On paper, they're saying it's all about security, but at what cost? £3.4bn is a big chunk of change 💸. And let's be real, if the US is cool with it, that's gotta count for something 😐. I mean, Trump's not exactly known for his diplomacy skills 😉. But seriously, this deal does feel like a bit of a give-and-take. The UK gets to keep their military base, but they're giving up control over the islands... it's not entirely clear what they're gaining here 🤷‍♀️.

I think we need to take a step back and think about why this deal is happening in the first place 👊. Is it really all about security, or is there something more at play? We can't just dismiss Trump's criticism without considering his point of view either 🙏. This feels like one of those international diplomacy things where everyone's got an opinion, but nobody's really listening to each other 🗣️.
 
I'm a bit surprised they're doing this, you know? I mean, £3.4bn is a lot of money 🤑, but if it's just gonna be used to lease back Diego Garcia then isn't that kinda counterproductive? And what about the people who actually live there? They've been displaced for years already... 🤔 It feels like the UK is more worried about its own interests than about doing what's right. I'm not sure why Trump thinks it's an "act of great stupidity", but if anyone knows, it's gotta be someone who's actually paying attention to this stuff 🤷‍♂️
 
I'm literally shook by this news 😱... The UK is just giving away a massive chunk of land to Mauritius while keeping control of the military base on Diego Garcia? 🤔 I don't get it... How can they justify that? £3.4bn and all for what? 🤑 It's like they're making a profit off the back of Mauritius! 💸 And what about the people who were forcibly displaced from their homes to make way for this deal? 😢 The UK is basically saying "hey, we'll give you some cash, but you can't have the land" - it's so patronising 🙄. I'm team Kemi Badenoch all the way 👊
 
I think the whole thing is super weird... 🤔 The UK's getting £3.4bn from us and we're supposed to be grateful? I mean, it was our land they just took away without even giving us a fair chance to decide what to do with it... Mauritius has a point there. And then they're selling it back to us but for like 99 years in exchange for some cash... 🤑 Sounds like we're getting robbed either way?
 
I'm all about being organized and stuff 📝. I mean, can you imagine having a million tabs open on your browser with no way to close them? 😱 It's like, what if you're trying to research something but every other tab is just taking up space? That's why I use the Pomodoro Technique – work for 25 minutes, then take a 5-minute break 🕒️. It's like a productivity dream come true! 💤
 
I gotta disagree with the UK's move 🙅‍♂️. I think they're making a huge mistake by giving away the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. £3.4bn is still a ton of cash, but it's not worth risking the security of the UK's military base on Diego Garcia. Trump might have said it was stupid, but at least he's being honest 🤷‍♂️. The fact that the US is backing the deal shows they must see something the UK doesn't, and I'm not convinced that paying off Mauritius will be enough to keep them happy. It's a classic case of throwing money at a problem instead of finding a long-term solution 💸.
 
🤔 I don't get why the US is so salty about this 🙄... like what's up with Trump? He's all like "act of great stupidity" but does he have a better solution? 🤑 Anyway, the fact that they're making a big deal out of it just shows how important those islands are to them 🌴. I'm kinda curious to see what happens next though... will the UK and Mauritius actually make this work? ⏱️
 
Back
Top