Trump’s peace plan is just about holding together, but may be unravelled by two unresolved issues | Rajan Menon

Trump's Peace Plan: A F fragile Foundation for Gaza's Ceasefire

Donald Trump's long-awaited peace plan has finally been agreed upon by Israel and Hamas, bringing an end to two years of devastating violence in Gaza. The ceasefire that has come out of this agreement is a welcome development, with humanitarian aid starting to trickle into the territory and hostages being released. However, beneath the surface of these developments lies a complex web of unresolved issues that could yet unravel the entire plan.

At its core, the Trump plan's failure to specify a timeline for Israel's withdrawal from Gaza raises significant concerns about the ceasefire's long-term viability. Despite agreeing to pull back in stages, Israel will still control more than half of the territory, including the Philadelphi corridor adjacent to Gaza's border with Egypt - a key demand made by Hamas. Disputes over the pace and extent of this withdrawal could jeopardize the entire agreement.

Furthermore, the plan's vagueness on issues such as disarmament and the deployment of an international stabilisation force (ISF) in Gaza is particularly worrying. Hamas has long insisted that Israel must leave all of Gaza as part of any ceasefire deal, but the Trump plan falls short of this commitment. The lack of monitoring and verification provisions for these key issues only adds to the uncertainty.

The absence of trust between Hamas and Israel makes these disputes even more likely to escalate into violence. Yechiel Leiter's statement that Israel would remain in Gaza until Hamas disarms fully is a stark reminder of the deep-seated mistrust between the two parties. Netanyahu's vow to resume the war if Gaza isn't "demilitarised" only adds to this sense of unease.

The international community's willingness to support the Trump plan without providing concrete commitments on key issues such as the ISF further undermines its credibility. If Israel were to begin intervening in Gaza again, citing security threats, it's hard to imagine the ISF resisting - a scenario that could rapidly destabilize the entire region.

In conclusion, while the ceasefire in Gaza is a welcome development, the Trump plan's foundation remains fragile and susceptible to unraveling due to unresolved issues such as Israel's withdrawal from Gaza, disarmament, and the deployment of an international stabilisation force. Unless these concerns are addressed, the rest of the plan - including continued aid deliveries and economic reconstruction - may remain aspirational rather than achievable.

the trump plan is just a smokescreen ... they're just trying to distract us from the real issue: israel's grip on gaza isn't gonna let go easily, period. what's with all this vague stuff about withdrawl and disarmament? seems like just an excuse for them to keep their soldiers in there and collect more funds from aid ... meanwhile, hamas gets left holding the bag, and we're supposed to be rooting for them? no thanks

[Image of a cartoon Trump with a broken peace plan in the background]

Israel's withdrawal from Gaza ️

[Animation of a clock ticking away, with Israel still controlling half of Gaza]

Hamas wants ALL of Gaza ️

[Hamster wheel with Netanyahu saying "I'll never leave"]

International community: "Just trust us "

Aid deliveries on hold until issues are solved

Trump plan: fragile foundation

lol what a mess this plan is like they thought everything would just magically work out with Israel and Hamas just chillin' over a nice cup of tea meanwhile the Philadelphi corridor is still gonna be controlled by Israel which is just not cool, dont think so and disarmament? yeah right like that's ever gonna happen especially if Netanyahu has his way international stabilisation force aka an excuse for Israel to stick its nose in every tiny thing in Gaza can't wait to see this all blow up in their faces

I mean, can you believe it? The US is backing this whole peace deal in Gaza but there's all these holes in it . I'm not saying Trump didn't have his intentions good, but come on... Israel still gets to control half the territory and that doesn't exactly fill me with confidence . And what about Hamas' demand for a full withdrawal? It's like they're just gonna keep on fighting till someone gives in .

I'm all for some peace in Gaza, but we need more than just a plan - we need action . The international community needs to step up and make sure these issues get resolved before things go south again . Can't have the whole region destabilized just because of some fine print .

I'm still on edge about this whole thing... I mean, a ceasefire in Gaza is a good start, but have you seen the fine print? It's like they're just scratching the surface of what needs to be done. Israel's gonna stay in Gaza for who knows how long, and Hamas is still not convinced. What if it all falls apart because of some minor disagreement? And what about that international stabilisation force? Is it even a real thing now? I don't know, man... It feels like they're just setting the stage for more problems down the line.

i just saw this news about trump's peace plan and honestly it sounds like a recipe for disaster . i mean i get that israel wants to keep some control over gaza but come on, half of the territory? that's just gonna fuel more animosity towards israel. and what's up with no timeline for withdrawal? doesn't make sense to me. also, the lack of monitoring and verification provisions for disarmament is super concerning . how are we supposed to trust that both sides will stick to the agreement if there's no way to hold them accountable?

this whole thing feels like a Band-Aid on a bullet wound... how about actual timelines and commitments instead of empty promises?

The Trump peace plan, a fleeting respite for Gaza's battered populace ... it raises so many questions about the nature of 'peace' itself. Is it a temporary reprieve from the storm, or merely a Band-Aid on an unhealed wound? The lack of concrete commitments from key stakeholders - Israel, Hamas, and the international community alike - speaks to our collective inability to grasp the complexity of this conflict.

It's almost as if we're trying to impose order on chaos by cobbling together half-baked solutions . The absence of trust between Hamas and Israel is palpable, and it's disturbing to see Netanyahu's words being taken at face value... doesn't that just perpetuate a cycle of mistrust? And what about the long-term implications of this plan? Are we merely delaying the inevitable, or have we finally stumbled upon a path forward?

As I ponder these questions, I'm reminded of the power of nuance and subtlety in conflict resolution. It's easy to get caught up in grand gestures and lofty rhetoric, but true progress requires a deep understanding of the intricacies at play . The Trump plan may be a welcome development, but it's only the beginning - we must continue to push for more comprehensive solutions that address the root causes of this conflict...

I'm not sure about this Trump peace plan... it seems like a Band-Aid solution to a much deeper problem. Israel's gonna keep a chunk of Gaza, which is just setting up more tensions with Hamas. And what's with the vague language on disarmament and an international stabilisation force? It feels like a lot of hot air, you know? I'm all for peace, but we need to address the underlying issues here if this plan is gonna have any real chance of sticking.

I don't usually comment but... I'm worried about this whole deal . Like, I get that a ceasefire is better than nothing, but what's gonna happen when all these issues come back to bite us? Israel still gets to control half the territory and Hamas is still all like "you gotta leave everything" and it just seems like a recipe for disaster . And don't even get me started on the lack of monitoring - what if Israel just ignores all the deal's terms and starts bombing Gaza again? It's like, we should be supporting these kinds of agreements, but at the same time, we gotta keep our eyes open to potential problems . I'm not trying to be a downer or anything, but can't we just have some concrete commitments on these key issues before we start celebrating?

I'm so late to the party but... I gotta say, Trump's peace plan sounds like a bunch of hot air to me . I mean, I get why people are optimistic about the ceasefire and all, but have we forgotten that this is just Israel and Hamas playing nice for now? It's gonna take a lot more than a few empty promises to fix the deep-seated issues between these two parties .

And what's with the international community just rubber-stamping this plan without putting in any real effort to make it work? I mean, if we're talking about deploying an ISF in Gaza, that requires actual resources and commitment from everyone involved . Until then, we can just keep hoping for the best (yawn).

This peace plan is like building a house on shaky ground . I mean, Trump's plan doesn't really add up, you know? Israel's still gonna be in control of most of Gaza, which means there's no real way for Hamas to disarm and trust the ceasefire. And what about Netanyahu saying he'll go back to war if things don't go his way? That's just gonna create more tension and violence. The international community is basically just going along with this plan without making any real commitments, which makes it super weak. I'm not buying it until there are concrete steps taken to address these major issues .