"British politicians walk a tightrope as they navigate the complexities of asylum policy, but one Home Secretary's comments have sparked outrage among Albanians.
Labour's Shabana Mahmood recently singled out around 700 Albanian families living in taxpayer-funded accommodation after failing their asylum claims during a speech about reforming the asylum system. The figure is a statistical drop in the ocean of Britain's post-Brexit challenges, according to Prime Minister Edi Rama.
Rama has repeatedly clashed with British politicians over their descriptions of Albanians, and his response to Mahmood's comments only adds fuel to the fire. "How can a Labour Home Secretary so poorly echo the rhetoric of the populist far-right – and single out 700 Albanian families... precisely at a moment when the UK and Albania have built one of Europe's most successful partnerships on illegal migration?" Rama tweeted.
The Prime Minister also pointed out that Albanians are net contributors to the British economy, with the number of Albanians receiving UK benefits very low relative to other communities. "To single them out again and again is not policy – it is a troubling and indecent exercise in demagoguery," he said.
Mahmood's comments have been widely condemned by Albanian politicians and civil society groups, who see them as an example of ethnic stereotyping. The Home Secretary has defended her words, saying that she was simply trying to address the "crisis" in the asylum system.
The debate highlights the challenges faced by refugees and asylum seekers in Britain, particularly those from Albania. With over 13,000 people deported back to the country since a returns deal was signed in 2022, many are still living in limbo. The UK's approach to asylum policy has been heavily criticized for being "out of control" and "unfair".
The government's plans to make refugee status temporary and extend the wait for permanent settlement have also sparked controversy. Critics argue that these measures will disproportionately affect vulnerable communities.
As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: the UK's asylum policy must be reformed to better address the needs of refugees and asylum seekers. Politicians like Edi Rama are pushing for a more humane approach, one that prioritizes fairness and equality over politics and rhetoric."
Labour's Shabana Mahmood recently singled out around 700 Albanian families living in taxpayer-funded accommodation after failing their asylum claims during a speech about reforming the asylum system. The figure is a statistical drop in the ocean of Britain's post-Brexit challenges, according to Prime Minister Edi Rama.
Rama has repeatedly clashed with British politicians over their descriptions of Albanians, and his response to Mahmood's comments only adds fuel to the fire. "How can a Labour Home Secretary so poorly echo the rhetoric of the populist far-right – and single out 700 Albanian families... precisely at a moment when the UK and Albania have built one of Europe's most successful partnerships on illegal migration?" Rama tweeted.
The Prime Minister also pointed out that Albanians are net contributors to the British economy, with the number of Albanians receiving UK benefits very low relative to other communities. "To single them out again and again is not policy – it is a troubling and indecent exercise in demagoguery," he said.
Mahmood's comments have been widely condemned by Albanian politicians and civil society groups, who see them as an example of ethnic stereotyping. The Home Secretary has defended her words, saying that she was simply trying to address the "crisis" in the asylum system.
The debate highlights the challenges faced by refugees and asylum seekers in Britain, particularly those from Albania. With over 13,000 people deported back to the country since a returns deal was signed in 2022, many are still living in limbo. The UK's approach to asylum policy has been heavily criticized for being "out of control" and "unfair".
The government's plans to make refugee status temporary and extend the wait for permanent settlement have also sparked controversy. Critics argue that these measures will disproportionately affect vulnerable communities.
As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: the UK's asylum policy must be reformed to better address the needs of refugees and asylum seekers. Politicians like Edi Rama are pushing for a more humane approach, one that prioritizes fairness and equality over politics and rhetoric."
... like, how can we just single out an entire community of people who are already struggling to make a life for themselves? It's not right, you know? I've got a few friends who are Albanian and they're all good people, some of them are even doing really well in the UK. The fact that 700 families are being singled out because of their nationality is just outrageous 
.
.
. Edi Rama is right on the money when he says it's demagoguery... we need more leaders who are willing to listen and have tough conversations, not just throw around numbers and statistics like they're going out of style 
.
Albanian families being singled out by Home Sec is low-key racist tho 
. I've got friends who have been living in the UK for years, they're good people, hardworking, and they contribute to society. Why should we punish those who can't even get their asylum claims right? 
. It's not like Albanians are some kind of "undesirable" group or anything... we need more understanding and empathy in politics, you know? 
I don't think it's right that Shabana Mahmood is targeting Albanian families who aren't getting anywhere in the asylum system. It feels like she's stigmatizing an entire community instead of trying to find a solution. 
The fact that Albanians are actually contributing to the economy and paying taxes seems to get lost in the conversation. 
I don't get why Shabana Mahmood had to single out those 700 Albanian families... it's just not right 
. And I'm not even going to get into the fact that these families are already in limbo, stuck in accommodation that's meant for people who can't make their asylum claims work 
. It's time for the government to take a more humane approach and focus on supporting everyone, regardless of where they're from 
.
.
. And those plans to make refugee status temporary? Unbelievable 
. We can do better, UK! 
its all about the politics & rhetoric instead of actually helpin ppl in need 
I'm so worried about these 700 Albanian families being singled out! They're just trying to build a new life in the UK 
. I think Edi Rama is right to call out Shabana Mahmood's comments - it's demagoguery at its worst 
. It's time for politicians to put aside their differences and work towards a more humane approach 
I mean, what's up with this Home Secretary, right? She goes out there and singles out 700 Albanian families who didn't make it in the asylum system... like, what's her strategy, trying to drum up support for her party by pitting them against other groups? 
It's just so unfair. And PM Edi Rama is right to call out Labour for echoing the rhetoric of the far-right - how can they be so clueless? 
. Can't we all just try to be a little more empathetic and understanding? 
. I hope his message resonates with politicians on both sides of the aisle and encourages them to put people over politics.
. Every voice that speaks out against injustice is a reminder that we can make a difference 
- we're human beings too! It's not fair to single out one community just because they're from a specific country.
It's all about playing the victim and stoking fear among certain groups, if you ask me. And what's with the whole "demagoguery" thing? Is she trying to deflect attention from her own policy failures? The stats on Albanians contributing to the economy are definitely telling, but is that enough to justify singling out an entire group of people? 