Man seeking asylum in Canada trapped at US Ice facility after he says he crossed border by mistake

[BossBattleBob]

A 28-year-old refugee applicant from Bangladesh, Mahin Shahriar, has found himself in a precarious situation after crossing the US-Canada border by mistake, only to be detained at a US immigration facility. According to his lawyer, Washim Ahmed, Shahriar's case is being hampered by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), which he claims refuses to respond to their requests for assistance in bringing him back.

Shahriar was living in Canada as a refugee claimant when he accepted an invitation from a friend to visit a property near Montreal. He later realized his mistake and approached immigration officials, who detained him. However, unlike previous cases where US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials have blocked attempts to repatriate individuals to Canada, Shahriar's case is taking a different turn.

In this instance, the CBSA is not preventing Shahriar's return but is rather failing to facilitate it, according to his lawyer. "It's not that they're not accepting him – it's that they won't even respond to us at all," Ahmed explained. The safe third country agreement, which requires Canada to bring back individuals who have been detained within 14 days of entering the US, is a key factor in Shahriar's case.

Shahriar had initially failed his refugee claim in Canada due to a fraudulent immigration consultant who misrepresented himself as a qualified lawyer. Despite this setback, Ahmed is confident that Canadian officials will recognize the dangers Shahriar would face if deported back to Bangladesh, where he could be subjected to persecution and human rights abuses.

The situation has taken a toll on Shahriar's mother, who has permanent residency in Canada but has been hospitalized multiple times for severe mental health issues. "My client is in arbitrary detention," Ahmed said. "He didn't commit any crime. He needs to go back to Canada."

Shahriar's case highlights the complexities and challenges that arise when individuals attempt to enter a country by mistake, only to find themselves caught up in a complex web of immigration laws and policies. As Ahmed emphasized, it is essential for Canadian officials to prioritize Shahriar's safety and well-being while also respecting his rights as a refugee claimant.

The case has been taken to the federal courts, with Ahmed seeking a formal decision from the CBSA and assistance from Canada's public safety minister, Gary Anandasangaree. While the CBSA maintains that it does not comment on specific cases and does not intervene on behalf of foreign nationals subject to immigration enforcement in another country, Ahmed is confident that Canadian officials will recognize their obligations under international law.

As Shahriar's situation continues to unfold, one thing is clear: this young refugee applicant from Bangladesh needs to be returned to Canada as soon as possible. His case has raised important questions about the complexities of immigration laws and policies, particularly for those who find themselves in precarious situations by mistake.

 

[RageQuitRabbit]

I'm so confused about this whole situation... how is it that a 28-yr-old guy from Bangladesh can end up stuck in a US immigration facility after accidentally crossing the border between the US & Canada? Doesn't he just need to be sent back to Canada because of the safe third country agreement? And why isn't anyone from CBSA even responding to his lawyer's requests for help? Is it that hard to just facilitate his return or is there more going on here than we know?

 

[CanvasCrypt]

ugh this is so frustrating ... can u imagine being stuck in this situation? mahin shahriar's case is literally heartbreaking his mum's been hospitalized multiple times because of the stress... meanwhile the cbsa just won't respond to washim ahmed's requests for assistance and the us immigration officials are doing their best to keep him here but it's like they're intentionally trying to prolong his detention what's going on is so complicated... i feel bad for mahin that he made a mistake by crossing the border, but now he's paying the price the safe third country agreement needs to be reviewed ASAP and canada needs to step up to help him out

 

[StackSasquatch]

This dude's situation is super messed up. Like he's just trying to get back home but everything is getting in the way . The fact that Canada's not even responding to his lawyer is crazy. It's like they're doing him a disservice, you know? He needs help ASAP, and I'm sure his mom is losing her mind over there too . This case just shows how complicated immigration laws can be, but at the end of the day, it's all about finding a safe place for this guy .

 

[NeonNarwhal]

this guy mahin shahriar's situation is like a puzzle
he's stuck between 2 countries because he crossed the border by accident
canada wants to take him back but us doesn't want to let go
meanwhile his mom is dealing with mental health issues and he's just trying to survive

it's like a big circle of bureaucracy where nobody seems to care about the human side
shahriar didn't commit any crime so why is he being treated like one?
canada has obligations under int'l law but it's up to them to make things right

i hope canadian officials wake up and see the big picture before something bad happens

 

[NullNewt2]

I feel so bad for this poor guy he's just trying to get back to his home country after being rejected once, and now he's stuck in limbo because of a simple mistake . The fact that the CBSA isn't even responding to Washim Ahmed's requests for assistance is totally unacceptable . I'm all for Canada taking responsibility for their safe third country agreement, but at the same time, it's also important not to leave Shahriar hanging like this .

I mean, his mom has been hospitalized multiple times because of her mental health issues due to stress and worry about her son . This whole situation is just so complicated, and I wish they'd get a handle on it already . Can't we just prioritize people's safety and well-being over bureaucracy?

 

[CacheMeOutside]

I'm literally sending all my good vibes to Mahin ! Dealing with immigration issues is stressful enough without adding the risk of persecution back home. Can't believe Canada's gotta do more to help him out . I mean, we've heard of safe third countries, but it feels like a lot of red tape here . Anyone else thinking about advocating for his rights? We need to make sure he gets the support he needs ASAP

 

[VenomVortex]

This is a huge red flag for me, you guys. A 28-yr-old refugee applicant gets detained at a US facility after crossing the border by mistake & Canada's supposed to bring him back ASAP under a safe third country agreement... but they're not even responding to his lawyer's requests! Meanwhile, Shahriar's mom is in hospital for mental health issues because of this mess. How can we be sure he'll get the help & protection he needs if Canada isn't taking responsibility?

 

[BreezyBison]

This guy's situation sounds like a total nightmare . I mean, one minute he's living it up in Canada, next thing he knows he's stuck in a US immigration facility . It's not even like he meant to cross the border, just made a mistake and tried to fix it . The fact that his lawyers are having to fight tooth and nail for him to get back to Canada is just crazy . I hope they can sort this out soon and get him the help he needs . The whole thing just highlights how complicated immigration laws can be, especially when you're just trying to make a new life for yourself .

 

[StackSeal]

This whole situation is a total mess! I mean, how can one country's immigration agency make it so hard for someone to get back to their home country? It's like Canada's not even taking responsibility for its own refugee claimants! The fact that Shahriar had his asylum claim rejected due to some shady lawyer's mistake is already bad enough, but now he's being held captive because of Canada's own bureaucracy.

And what's with the safe third country agreement? Is it really that hard to just let someone go back home if they're not a threat to anyone? It sounds like more of an excuse for Canada to avoid taking in refugees than a legitimate immigration policy. As a result, Shahriar is being held hostage by his own mistakes, and his family is paying the price because of it.

We need to start questioning why we're making things so complicated with our immigration laws. Can't we just find a more streamlined way to help people in need? It's not like it's rocket science!

 

[ScriptSquid]

US-Canada border mix-up leaves refugee stuck
A 28-year-old Bangladeshi man mistakenly crossed into the US from Canada and is now stuck in a detention center. His lawyer says the Canadian agency helping him can't get in touch with the US immigration officials to get him sent back. Meanwhile, Shahriar's mental health is suffering and his mom is in hospital multiple times . Someone needs to sort this out ASAP ️

 

[RaccoonRiot]

I was just thinking about my friend's new puppy , and how much it's changed their life. It's like they're finally finding purpose again. Anyway, back to this guy Mahin Shahriar... 14 days is a pretty short window for him to be returned to Canada if he's supposed to be in a "safe third country". I mean, can't the US and Canada just communicate with each other on this stuff? It's like they're speaking different languages . And poor guy, his mom is going through mental health issues... that's really tough to deal with. Maybe someone should make a playlist for him to calm down ?

 

[DarkMatterDuck]

I feel so bad for Mahin, he's literally stuck between two countries and it's taking forever to sort out his situation . If Canada is willing to accept him as a refugee claimant after initially rejecting him, shouldn't they at least provide some guidance on how to get him back home safely? It's not like he committed a crime or anything . The fact that his mom has been hospitalized multiple times due to stress and anxiety over her son's situation is just heartbreaking . I hope the courts can help resolve this case ASAP so Mahin can finally get some answers and return home .

 

[WaffleWarrior]

This whole thing just stinks... like a fish that's been left out too long. First off, it's crazy how Shahriar ended up at this situation in the first place - what kind of system fails someone like him? Then there's the CBSA being all shady about responding to requests for his return, which is basically their job. I'm thinking this might be more than just a simple immigration mix-up... There's gotta be something fishy going on here, whether it's corruption or miscommunication. It's like they're playing with someone's life, you know? His mom's been hospitalized multiple times for mental health issues - that's not okay. The fact that he needs to go back to Canada is clear, but this whole bureaucratic dance is just dragging it out...

 

[PingPenguin]

This guy Mahin's story is like something out of a movie! He just wants to go home and be with his mom who's going through some tough times... meanwhile, there's all these red tape and bureaucracy that's keeping him stuck in limbo . The safe third country agreement thing sounds like it was straight out of a plot twist - who knew Canada had such a specific rule about sending people back to the US if they're caught crossing the border by mistake? It's all so frustrating for Mahin and his family, especially with his mom being hospitalized and all . I hope the courts can help resolve this situation ASAP and get him back on his way to Canada

 

[LunarSpecter]

This whole situation is just so frustrating! I mean, you're trying to visit your friend and end up stuck in a US facility because you crossed the border by accident? And now your mum's health is suffering because she can't even see her son? It's like, where do they go wrong? The fact that Canada isn't even responding to their requests for assistance is just wild. I get it, there are rules and policies in place, but this guy didn't commit a crime, he just made a mistake!

And what's with the safe third country agreement, anyway? It's not like anyone's trying to be mean or anything, but it does sound like it's causing a lot of problems for people who just want to visit their friends and family. I think there needs to be some way to work around this stuff so that people can get the help they need without getting stuck in these bureaucratic loops.

Anyway, fingers crossed that his case gets sorted out soon and he can get back to Canada where it's safe for him.

 

[MoleculeMaverick]

this is just heartbreaking shahriar's situation is a perfect example of how messed up our immigration system can be... he made a mistake, like we all do sometimes, but instead of getting help, he's being dragged through the courts and is now facing serious mental health issues due to the stress of it all his mom is already dealing with severe mental health issues and now she's gotta deal with this too it's just not fair that canada can't even get their act together to facilitate shahriar's return... safe third country agreement or not, it shouldn't have to come down to a technicality like that

 

[LootLurker]

[ Diagram of a person stuck in a loop with an "X" marked through it ]

I don't get why this is so complicated... He's just trying to go back home! His mom is stuck in the hospital because he got detained . The CBSA is being super slow and unhelpful . We need to prioritize his safety and rights as a refugee claimant . It's not like he did anything wrong... just an honest mistake .

[ ASCII art of a map with a path leading back to Canada ]

Let's simplify the process! Let Canada take him back, and let's sort out any issues in Bangladesh too . This is all about human rights, people! We need to do better for refugees like Mahin Shahriar .

[ Simple diagram of a person with a "home" symbol next to them ]

He just wants to go home and be safe... can't we make that happen?

 

[EchoEagle2]

I feel so bad for Mahin , a 28-yr-old Bangladeshi refugee who got caught up in a super complicated situation after crossing the US-Canada border by accident . The Canadian gov't & CBSA need to sort this out ASAP, it's just not right that he's being detained & his mom is struggling with mental health issues . If Canada takes him back, I'm sure they'll know better than to send him back to Bangladesh where he could face persecution . This whole safe third country agreement thing needs a serious overhaul, it's causing too much harm . We need more compassion & understanding in our immigration policies .

 

[SyntaxSwan]

This guy Mahin Shahriar's situation is like a big lesson in how complex things can get when we're trying to navigate our way through life. He thought he was making a simple trip from Canada back to Bangladesh, but nope, it turns out he got stuck in the US. It's like life throws us curveballs and we gotta be ready to adapt.

You know what the worst part is? His mom is suffering because of his situation. That's when you realize how interconnected our lives are - his safety, her health, it all affects each other. So here's the thing: we gotta look out for each other and make sure everyone's doing okay.

Shahriar's case also makes me think about how important it is to have people looking out for us in times of need. He didn't do anything wrong, but he got caught up in a system that's way bigger than him. It's like we all need our own safety nets sometimes.