Kim Kardashian's foray into television as a lead actress in Ryan Murphy's new series "All's Fair" has been met with widespread criticism, and not just because of her infamous family dynamics. The show follows the lives of three powerful women - Liberty (Naomi Watts), Karla (Kim Kardashian) and Maya (Niecy Nash) - who run an all-female law firm that specializes in helping wealthy women navigate their messy divorces.
The problem lies not only with the cringe-worthy performances from the lead actresses, but also with a script that seems to have been written by a committee of people who just can't seem to get it right. The show's attempts at female empowerment and self-discovery fall flat, as its characters are reduced to cartoonish caricatures of strong women who will stop at nothing to get what they want.
Kim Kardashian's portrayal of Karla, a shallow and selfish woman who is only interested in her own wealth and status, is particularly grating. Her character's dialogue is often awkwardly phrased and feels like it was written by someone who just doesn't understand what it means to be a strong woman. Meanwhile, Naomi Watts' Liberty comes across as equally one-dimensional, with her character's motivations feeling like they're driven by something called "drama" rather than any real sense of purpose.
Despite the show's many missteps, Niecy Nash is the only bright spot in an otherwise dull and unengaging series. Her performance as Maya is a highlight of each episode, bringing a sense of much-needed depth and nuance to a role that could have easily been reduced to a shallow stereotype.
But even Nash's best efforts can't save "All's Fair" from its overall sense of malaise. The show feels like it's trying too hard to be something it's not - a female-led drama that takes itself seriously but ultimately ends up feeling like a shallow exercise in feminism.
Ultimately, the problems with "All's Fair" are twofold: its poor writing and acting. It's clear that no one involved in the production has any real sense of what they're doing, leading to a show that feels like it's just phoning it in from start to finish. If you value your sanity, stay far away from this mess.
In short, "All's Fair" is a disaster - and not just because of Kim Kardashian's involvement. It's a show that fails on nearly every level, with its cringe-worthy performances, awkward dialogue, and shallow exploration of feminist themes. Disney+ deserves better than this.
The problem lies not only with the cringe-worthy performances from the lead actresses, but also with a script that seems to have been written by a committee of people who just can't seem to get it right. The show's attempts at female empowerment and self-discovery fall flat, as its characters are reduced to cartoonish caricatures of strong women who will stop at nothing to get what they want.
Kim Kardashian's portrayal of Karla, a shallow and selfish woman who is only interested in her own wealth and status, is particularly grating. Her character's dialogue is often awkwardly phrased and feels like it was written by someone who just doesn't understand what it means to be a strong woman. Meanwhile, Naomi Watts' Liberty comes across as equally one-dimensional, with her character's motivations feeling like they're driven by something called "drama" rather than any real sense of purpose.
Despite the show's many missteps, Niecy Nash is the only bright spot in an otherwise dull and unengaging series. Her performance as Maya is a highlight of each episode, bringing a sense of much-needed depth and nuance to a role that could have easily been reduced to a shallow stereotype.
But even Nash's best efforts can't save "All's Fair" from its overall sense of malaise. The show feels like it's trying too hard to be something it's not - a female-led drama that takes itself seriously but ultimately ends up feeling like a shallow exercise in feminism.
Ultimately, the problems with "All's Fair" are twofold: its poor writing and acting. It's clear that no one involved in the production has any real sense of what they're doing, leading to a show that feels like it's just phoning it in from start to finish. If you value your sanity, stay far away from this mess.
In short, "All's Fair" is a disaster - and not just because of Kim Kardashian's involvement. It's a show that fails on nearly every level, with its cringe-worthy performances, awkward dialogue, and shallow exploration of feminist themes. Disney+ deserves better than this.
her character feels like a caricature of a wealthy woman who only cares about herself & it's just so unrelatable y'know? & dont even get me started on the writing, its like they took all the best parts of female empowerment & turned them into cardboard cutouts 
. naomi watts & niecy nash are the only ones trying to elevate this show but even their performances cant save it from being a total mess 
overall i'd say stay far away from disney+ if you wanna see some real drama 
Kim Kardashian trying to be serious actress? 
She looks like she's just winging it on set 
. Nah, can't Disney+ afford better talent? 
. Kim Kardashian's character, Karla, is literally the definition of toxic femininity 
... it's cringeworthy at times and just feels like a lazy attempt to tackle complex issues like feminism and self-discovery.
- she's always been a talented actress, but here she shines as Maya. The problem is that even her amazing performance can't save the show from its overall lackluster vibe 
. It just feels like "All's Fair" is phoning it in and not really putting in any effort to make it work.
. Disney+ deserves way better than this, imo 
.
I'm low-key surprised by how much I agree with this thread 
Meanwhile, shows like "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel" which premiered on the same platform are doing way better in terms of critical acclaim and viewership 
.
You'd think that kind of clout would translate to a decent acting gig 
. But I guess the old adage is true: if you've got it, flaunt it... not necessarily act in a TV show.
Maybe they just need to focus on creating more quality content rather than relying on celebrity cameos and formulaic dramas 
.
like they took every bad 90s movie about powerful women and mashed them all together. i dont get why kim kardashian is even in it, shes not exactly known for her acting skills 
.
from itself. Overall, I'd say stay far away from "All's Fair" unless you wanna watch a bunch of powerful women do nothing but fight over their husbands' money 
i mean disney+ is better than this btw dont waste your time on "all's fair" 
. Niecy Nash is the real MVP here, bringing some much-needed sass and depth to her role... but sadly, not enough to save this trainwreck of a show 
. And honestly, if I want to watch a bunch of rich women arguing over money, I can just look at my ex's Instagram stories